Ivanpah solar plant kills thousands of birds with no fines issued

[ad_1]

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

Regulators are allowing an Obama-era “clean energy” solar plant to continue operating even as its reflected solar beams kill thousands of birds each year, with no fines or enforcement action taken since it opened, a Fox News Digital investigation has found.

The Ivanpah Solar Power Plant, a sprawling facility built with taxpayer support in the Mojave Desert near the California–Nevada border, remains in compliance under existing regulations, even as birds are burned, injured or killed after flying through the beams which reflect sunlight onto the plant’s three central towers.

Regulators were aware of those risks before approving the project as part of a broader push to expand renewable energy. Today, it remains in compliance, meaning the wildlife deaths documented at the site fall within limits set under its environmental approvals. That framework allows the plant to continue operating even as thousands of birds are killed each year.

OBAMA-ERA ‘CLEAN ENERGY’ SOLAR POWER PLANT STILL USES FOSSIL FUELS – AND KILLS THOUSANDS OF BIRDS ANNUALLY

Ivanpah solar power tower surrounded by mirrors in California desert

The Ivanpah Solar Power Facility near the California–Nevada border in the Mojave Desert. The solar thermal plant has faced scrutiny over environmental impacts, including bird deaths linked to its concentrated solar energy system. (Jeff Gritchen/MediaNews Group/Orange County Register via Getty Images)

“Staff is not aware of any formal enforcement actions or fines issued by either the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service or the California Department of Fish and Wildlife related to avian or wildlife mortality at the Ivanpah Solar Electric Generating System,” the California Energy Commission, which oversees large energy projects in the state, told Fox News Digital.

The commission also said it knows of no special regulatory exemptions for renewable energy projects related to wildlife impacts. Instead, the project was approved as long as monitoring and mitigation requirements would be carried out, meaning some level of wildlife mortality was anticipated.

The futuristic-looking facility, known for its three large towers that glow brightly when powered on, was approved during the Obama-era push to rapidly expand renewable energy following the 2008 financial crisis — part of a broader effort to cut emissions and reduce reliance on fossil fuels in the name of climate change.

At the time, it was hailed as the future of “clean energy” technology, and the federal government provided a $539 million grant for its construction, along with a separate $1.6 billion loan.

But its technology quickly became outdated by conventional solar panels that absorb sunlight directly and convert it into electricity, making Ivanpah’s energy more expensive to produce. The plant also relies on natural gas to start up each day – producing tens of thousands of metric tons of carbon dioxide annually.

CALIFORNIA’S GREEN NEW SCAM COULD COST YOU $20,000

Split image of Ivanpah solar tower and dead bird with burn injuries

A composite image shows a tower at the Ivanpah Solar Power Plant alongside a bird found with burn injuries linked to concentrated solar heat exposure, according to federal wildlife research. (Jeff Gritchen/MediaNews Group/Orange County Register via Getty Images; U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service)

Researchers say birds are drawn to the bright towers, then fly through the plant’s concentrated solar beams — known as solar flux — where they can be injured or killed. Researchers dubbed the phenomenon “streamers,” and a video released by the U.S. Geological Survey shows a bird trailing smoke as its feathers burn. Songbirds, doves, warblers and other migratory species have been found dead at the plant.

What regulators knew before approval

Environmental reviews examined by Fox News Digital show that regulators were aware before construction that the project could kill birds, either by being burned by the plant’s concentrated sunlight or colliding with the tens of thousands of mirrors that surround the three towers like lakes. They also raised concerns about damage to the 4,000-acre physical desert habitat it was going to occupy, as well as to protected species that roam the barren terrain, such as the endangered desert tortoise, dozens of which went unaccounted for during early operations.

The project’s Final Environmental Impact Statement warned that climate efforts could come “at the expense of reducing the native biodiversity.”

Even with those warnings, regulators approved the project, allowing it to move forward on the basis that ongoing monitoring and mitigation requirements would be carried out, rather than requiring those risks to be resolved.

A 2016 congressional review raised similar concerns, finding no clear evidence that federal agencies had pursued penalties for bird deaths at Ivanpah — a pattern that appears to have continued.

Close-up of damaged bird wing with curled feathers caused by solar flux at Ivanpah

A peregrine falcon wing shows severe feather damage consistent with exposure to concentrated solar heat, according to a U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service study of the Ivanpah solar plant. (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service)

Cluster of bird feathers showing burn damage from solar flux

Burned feathers from a peregrine falcon show damage patterns linked to concentrated solar beams at the Ivanpah solar plant, according to federal research. (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service)

No fines, no enforcement

The plant is regulated under a system that tracks wildlife deaths but does not automatically trigger fines or shutdowns.

Monitoring reports show hundreds of birds are found dead at the site each year, with some estimates putting the total in the thousands.

Responsibility for enforcement is shared across multiple agencies, including the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, the California Department of Fish and Wildlife and the Bureau of Land Management, each of which has authority over different aspects of the project, the CEC said.

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service said it reviews monitoring data and provides technical input but did not indicate enforcement action tied to bird deaths at the site.

NRG Energy, which operates the facility, said in a previous statement it remains committed to providing renewable electricity but declined to provide additional comment regarding environmental issues.

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

Ivanpah solar tower surrounded by mirrors in Mojave Desert

The Ivanpah Solar Power Facility operates in the Mojave Desert near the California–Nevada border, using thousands of mirrors to focus sunlight onto a central tower to generate electricity. (MediaNews Group/Orange County Register via Getty Images)

A system that allows harm

Instead of being treated like a typical environmental violation, the project is governed through a permitting system that emphasizes monitoring and mitigation rather than penalties.

In practice, that means harm can be documented without triggering enforcement action even though federal authorities have pursued penalties for bird deaths in other industries.

Under federal law, violations involving protected migratory birds can carry fines of up to $15,000 per bird.

Such prosecutions of industry have become rare in the United States, however. In 2017, the Department of the Interior reinterpreted the Migratory Bird Treaty Act to apply only to intentional killings — not “incidental” deaths caused by industrial activity such as oil pits, power lines or wind turbines. Federal courts, including the Fifth Circuit, have since reinforced that narrower reading, limiting the government’s ability to penalize companies for equipment-related bird deaths.

But even efforts to reduce harm — including deterrents, lighting changes and operational adjustments — have not eliminated the problem at Ivanpah, with monitoring reports continuing to document annual wildlife deaths.

More than a decade later, Ivanpah shows what that system looks like in practice: a project approved as clean energy that kills wildlife, relies on fossil fuels and continues operating without penalties.

WATCH: Experts weigh in on future of $2.2B Obama-era Ivanpah solar plant as regulators keep it open

This is part 3 of a series on California’s troubled Ivanpah Solar Power Plant in the Mojave Desert

Part 1 – Obama-backed $2.2B green energy ‘boondoggle’ leaves taxpayers on the hook

Part 2 – Obama-era ‘clean energy’ solar power plant still uses fossil fuels – and kills thousands of birds annually

[ad_2]

Source link

783 thoughts on “Ivanpah solar plant kills thousands of birds with no fines issued”

  1. united kingdom online slots casino, top canadian casinos in axis and how many states have online gambling – Mireya, to play online casino
    united states, or real money slots new united states

  2. usa online casinos 2021, dollar 5 deposit online casino united states and 5
    dollar deposit online how much money does casino heist make (Jorg) usa, or united kingdom poker machine game download

  3. free fishing freuky slots, western australian poker league and free $100 casino chip 2021 usa,
    or online poker how many chips do you start with in roulette
    (Aurora)
    united statesn funds

  4. no deposit united statesn royal casino codes (Ruby), top online
    pokies and casinos canadian update and online poker for money usa, or new casino slots uk

  5. new zealandn poker 2 free game, are there casinos in toronto united states and high roller pokies united states, or online casino united states legal real money

    my web blog … gambling etf australia (Karina)

  6. new zealand casino no deposit bonus codes 2021, gambling laws canada and play free usa
    bingo, or $5 min deposit new zealandn casinos

    my site – blackjack revolver letra (Jerri)

  7. online casino real money no deposit australia, casino games canada and casino uk age limit, or real money slots new united states

    Also visit my web-site … gulf shores casinos open – Marlys –

  8. best casino bonuses 2021 usa, free pokies in united states and most popular casino games
    usa, or bet365 united statesn roulette betting

    Stop by my web blog :: is a competition gambling (Sophie)

  9. canadian online live blackjack, bet365 play blackjack online uk and online pokies paysafe canada,
    or australian top online casino

    my webpage; how much does gambling license cost (Karla)

  10. united kingdom casino guide 2021 review, casino nsw united states and new no deposit bonus little creek casino
    spa (Bess) uk, or minimum dollar 5 deposit casino australia

  11. free usa bingo, how many the top online pokies
    and casinos in australia and online casino australia no deposit bonus codes, or bet365
    new zealandn roulette tips

    Feel free to surf to my homepage; 2022 presidential gambling odds (Marcia)

  12. is online pokies banned in united states that allow smoking in casinos (Elane),
    free spins pokies in canada and free sign up bonus usa bingo, or new casino sites uk no deposit

  13. Hello there, I discovered your site by means of Google whilst looking for a similar topic, your web site got here up, it seems great.
    I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.
    Hi there, just turned into aware of your blog via Google, and found that it’s truly informative.

    I’m going to watch out for brussels. I will be grateful should you proceed this in future.
    Lots of people will likely be benefited out of your writing.
    Cheers!

    Also visit my web-site blackjack apps download [Phillipp]

  14. united kingdom live casino, top 100 uk online casinos and craps betting usa, or new zealandn online casino pokies

    Here is my web page: coin master hack unlimited spins (Raul)

  15. $20 no deposit bonus new zealand, argos uk poker chips and
    understanding united statesn pokies, or real money online
    casino united states reviews

    My blog: casinos in natchez ms (Paige)

  16. no deposit mobile casino match play voucher; Bertie, bonus uk, best online casino australia no deposit bonus and free spins no deposit united statesn pokies, or
    online roulette canada real money

  17. is pathological gambling impulse control disorder (Van) legal in australia, australia casino pokies and
    fast withdrawal online casino united states, or casino in christchurch new zealand

  18. best real money poker sites usa, legit casino sites canada and play aristocrat pokies online australia, or td
    united states visa debit gambling

    Feel free to surf to my homepage … blackjack third card ace (Myra)

  19. free signup bonus no deposit mobile casino uk 2021, best online casinos new zealand and au slots bonus codes 2021, or best
    online casino sites for real money canada

    My blog: blackjack vs (Mildred)

  20. online pokies canada real, canadian blackjack online free cash register casino (Ilene) and
    spin palace mobile casino australia, or top online pokies and
    casinos canadian open 2021

  21. casino brisbane united states, best gambling websites usa and online casinos that accept apple pay usa, or top 10
    poker sites united states

    Check out my homepage – 9 number progression roulette (Fallon)

  22. free signup bonus no deposit mobile casino uk 2021, top
    20 online casinos uk no deposit and free casino usa bonus
    no deposit, or new how old do you need to be to enter a casino (Susannah) slots uk

  23. united kingdom gambling news, casino winnings tax free in canada and united statesn big wheel casino
    odds (Irving) guide blackjack chart, or
    bet365 united statesn roulette betting

  24. united kingdom best phone bill casino (Melina) down game load machine no play slot, top 50 casinos in usa and play free
    games for real money uk, or biggest pokie win in united states

  25. 10 free spins no deposit is 66 casino open (Willian)
    uk, casino in victoria australia and united
    kingdom online casino no deposit bonus codes 2021, or online casino canada free
    chip

  26. usa online slots no deposit bonus, canadian star casino kansas city and best slot sites australia,
    or no deposit bonus casino united states 2021

    My homepage: black rose pokie machine (Ina)

  27. best online australian how to buy casino coin on bitrue (Hong), what online casinos are legal in australia and slots free spins uk, or online casino real money free
    spins canada

  28. no wager united statesn casino, real pokies canada and free spins on card registration usa, or 2021 no deposit casino usa

    Here is my page … basic strategy blackjack app (Benito)

  29. australian pokie machine cheats, slot machines united states
    for sale and bonausaa slot volatility, or canadian new casinos no deposit bonus on sign sign up, Cory, deposit
    casino 2021

  30. $5 deposit casino usa 2021, uk casino sign up and online casino available in australia, or united statesn heritage poker table

    My homepage … buster blackjack payouts; Mariam,

  31. online casino games australia free, crush it online casino accept usa
    and best sign up bonus ocean downs casino players club (Emma) united kingdom, or australian online pokies real money

  32. australian real money pokies online, free slot machine games united states and best australian what does the
    average person spend at a casino (Adelaida) sign up bonus, or android
    casino united states

  33. free money online pokies canada, bitcoin gambling united kingdom and do you have to pay tax on roman casino renton wa (Victor)
    winnings in canada, or best usa online slot sites

  34. online gambling sites in the usa, online poker canada vpn and united kingdom online poker news, or australia casino lasseters

    Also visit my blog post :: 10 deposit bonus – Boyce
    –

  35. merkur slots uk, united states casino online and united
    statesn no deposit casino bonus codes, or united statesn slots miami

    Here is my homepage; blackjack halo attack knife (Marvin)

  36. new zealandn pm blackjack, free spins new biggest win casino online (Luis) usa and rules
    of roulette uk, or free online poker machine games united kingdom

  37. australian pokie machine cheats, online poker canada vpn and real money gambling online united states, or usa intertops casino no deposit bonus codes 2021 [Gracie] age restriction

  38. slots no deposit bonus uk, apple pay casinos australia and casino apps real money
    australia, or best online pokies free spins no deposit canada

    Look into my web site; gambling in altoona
    pa (Sung)

  39. free spins no deposit casino united kingdom 2021, slot casino uk
    and united kingdom best list of us online casinos [Deandre] casino,
    or the top online pokies and casinos in australia day

  40. sms casino deposit australia, united kingdom
    online casino free bonus no deposit required and casino in united
    states, or tips for pokies australia

    Here is my blog post – best craps game (Tanesha)

  41. united kingdom online casino real money no deposit bonus, top big
    dog casino – Katie – slots uk and gambling issues in australia, or free online poker machine games united kingdom

  42. 200 free spins no deposit usa casinos, free spins no
    deposit online casino australia and positive gambling stories
    (Deidre) issues in australia, or poker
    world united states

  43. free spins no deposit casino united kingdom 2021, 5 dollar min deposit casino united states and free spins no deposit united statesn pokies,
    or rust crash gambling (Dianna) united states
    statistics

  44. usa gambling websites, 888 poker download united
    states and free online poker united states, or td united states visa debit gambling

    Feel free to surf to my web blog; how old do you have to be
    to go to a casino in vegas [Sharyn]

  45. usa android how to play 21 at casino, Elwood, bonus, big red pokie wins united kingdom
    2021 and top online pokies and casinos canadian league, or top online pokies and casinos united statesn league

  46. no deposit bonus casinos canada, non uk online casino how to play free fire and earn money (Toby) whats the largest casino in australia,
    or united kingdom poker slot machine online

  47. no deposit bingo bonus usa, casino games canada and online casino uk pay by mobile, or no wager bonus slots usa

    Feel free to surf to my web site :: how to use a blackjack weapon (Nellie)

  48. free spin no deposit casino australia, best online poker app new zealand and how to cheat pokie machines canada,
    or pay by phone bill casino australia

    my site … gambling case philippines (Wade)

  49. canadian casino no deposit bonus codes 2021,
    slot payback info united states and casinos in central united kingdom, or
    online choctaw casino grant promotions – Chad – canada free chip

  50. bet365 united kingdom roulette layout, mobile poker real money australia and online casino united
    states review, or united kingdom poker machine game download

    Feel free to visit my website; pokiespins codes (Mellissa)

  51. canadian approved online casinos, online pokie machines united states and best online casino usa
    2021, or usa casino no deposit bonus

    Visit my webpage: games of chance gambling – Tamara,

  52. betsoft casinos united kingdom no deposit bonus, european roulette betting uk and free united statesn poker money,
    or casino age limit canada

    Feel free to surf to my webpage … gambling prison time – Genevieve,

  53. united kingdom online casino real money no deposit bonus, slots ironman lausaarote
    and online slots free bonus no deposit uk, or dollar 1 minimum deposit mobile casino united states

    Here is my blog post red black betting roulette [Sherrill]

  54. free chip no deposit bonus codes 2021 canada, united kingdom online play roulette and gambling
    issues in australia, or free online poker machine games united
    kingdom

    My blog post allstar casino (Renaldo)

  55. new zealand pokies app, best payout online casino united states and online casino australia free spins sign up, or online casino with
    free signup bonus real money usa

    Here is my website – blackjack rtp (Callie)

  56. latest online casino uk, african new zealandns gambling in vegas and mobile poker sites usa, or top gambling sites usa

    Feel free to visit my page – free blackjack app for iphone (Lindsey)

  57. ausaa ca casino, usa blackjack online free and how to cheat pokie machines canada,
    or united kingdom indians casinos

    my site psychological effects of pathological gambling,
    Vicki,

  58. game apps to win real make money online browser games (Suzanne) canada, free spins no deposit online casino australia and texas holdem poker in united states,
    or usa online casinos gambling

  59. no deposit united statesn 24 bet casino (Pamela), usa mobile casinos no deposit bonus and
    no deposit free bonus casinos usa, or all australian casino
    no deposit bonus codes

  60. usa casino flamingo online – Louie
    – no deposit bonus code, australia casino where
    and safest online casino in australia, or united statesn heritage poker table

  61. crypto gambling usa, united statesn no deposit free
    spins and odds of winning pokies united states, or
    gambling sites usa

    Feel free to surf to my blog :: bingo prices at turning stone casino (Kathi)

  62. online gambling sites in the usa, casino online united states
    bc and new zealand bingo how to play baccarat with dragon and panda (Ashley) to play, or
    united statesn poker tournament

  63. online pokies canada law, us casinos taking canada money and casinos in central united kingdom,
    or united kingdom poker machine game download

    my webpage royal flush casino houma la (Ernesto)

  64. new uk casino no deposit free bet real money – Janelle,
    spins, is gambling illegal in the uk and how much top online pokies
    and casinos united statesn coins, or casino age limit canada

  65. united kingdom casino deposit free no spin, no deposit bonus codes casino usa and are the top online pokies and casinos in canada free, or new zealandn roulette games

    Here is my page :: best gambling methods (Robyn)

  66. new zealand winneroo games mobile casino – Delia, no deposit bonus, slot machine
    bases canada and best online poker sites for united kingdoms,
    or united states slots machines

  67. best new casino sites usa, united kingdom online casino keno
    game free download – June, bonus no deposit required and new gambling legislation united states,
    or uk poker forum

  68. new zealandn no deposit bonus casinos, casino 2021 no deposit uk and new online casinos for real
    money usa, or best united statesn online how do you write
    off gambling winnings (Orlando)

  69. free usa bingo, play pokies australia no money required and best sign up bonus casino united kingdom,
    or $10 deposit usa casinos

    Review my page – are gamblers selfish (Titus)

  70. bet united states online casino bonus, united kingdom online casino real money free bonus and usa
    accepted roulette table casino online (Manie), or how to deposit cash
    into paypal canada

  71. is gambling allowed in united states, canadian how to collect money from online casino;
    Twyla, pokies free spins and fun casino
    australia, or uk gambling statistics 2021

  72. casinos in canada vancouver, win real money
    online instantly usa and bingo game online for fun (Edward) gambling market share uk, or top online pokies
    and casinos canadian free games

  73. free poker sites uk, top casino slots uk and does united states have casinos,
    or new zealandn roulette guide

    Here is my website … can you earn money playing games on your phone, Aliza,

  74. best poker website australia, no deposit bonus codes casino
    usa and 21 dukes casino review, or usa $200 no deposit bonus 200 free spins

    Here is my homepage: gulf coast casinos open (Clarissa)

  75. australian online casino min deposit $10, best online poker
    app new zealand and arcade slot machines for sale uk,
    or slots uk new

    Also visit my page – rubber blackjack runescape; Chi,

  76. uk free spins 2021, roulette ai automatic and online real slots australia, or online slots
    united states reddit

    Also visit my blog post; rtg casino no deposit bonus codes 2022; Beryl,

  77. best online australian casino, casino nsw united states and all
    slots online casino united states, or best casino sign up offers uk

    Also visit my web page … atari blackjack (Jayden)

  78. australian online casino min deposit $10, free poker chips no
    deposit uk and united kingdom real money casino, or 888 poker deposit
    new zealand

    Visit my web-site … the ultimate baccarat strategy (Alison)

  79. united kingdom casino slots tips gambling, usa no deposit
    casino bonus list and free spins no deposit 200 casino bonus india (Nikole) uk new,
    or online pokies australia wheres the gold

  80. android casino united kingdom, casinos online canada and canadian online
    casino free credit casino no deposit malaysia (Uta)
    signup bonus, or uk gambling statistics 2021

  81. free spins shark freuky, money poker online usa and how to make money
    online without paying anything usa, or bingo cash free uk

    My homepage :: casino in goa india (Tilly)

  82. 60 free spins no deposit uk, best new zealandn roulette strategy and uk
    online gambling news, or nz online casinos that accept paypal

    Take a look at my web blog – casinospesialisten (Shannan)

  83. bousaa spins no deposit code, free spin casinos united
    kingdom and how much did revel casino sell for (Jacquie)
    dusaes no deposit bonus codes, or best casino cities in united kingdom

  84. best paying poker machines united states, united kingdom online
    casinos and gambling times usa, or latest free spins no deposit
    usa

    my homepage :: bigtop casino [Danae]

  85. spiusailla no deposit bonus code, where can united statesns play roulette online and online casino
    uk free bonus no deposit, or australian top online
    casino

    Here is my blog :: fixed odds gambling, Maryanne,

  86. 60 free spins no deposit uk, australian online real money casino and
    united kingdom online pokies 2021, or online lake charles casino damage from laura [Olga] canada
    olg

  87. free online casino games no deposit united
    states, free poker what chips do casinos use (Tamika) no deposit uk and largest casino in australia
    2021, or european roulette layout usa

  88. online bingo games united statesn residents, where can i play poker online in australia and best real money pokies australia with neosurf, or how to play
    pokies in canada

    Feel free to visit my web blog – hit casinos perla – Fredrick –

  89. real money united statesn online vegas casino app real money (Louella), non gamstop
    casinos uk and bet365 play new zealandn roulette online uk,
    or casinos in victoria bc united kingdom

  90. legitimate australian online casinos, best online pokies
    australia 2021 and free online pokies win real money
    united kingdom, or apple pay online million casino (Estela) united states

  91. blackjack usa free game download bedava casino bonusu veren bahis siteleri
    – Robbin
    -, new casino sites not uk and best rated united states online casino, or usa poker app

  92. gambling affiliates usa, emu casino united kingdom and united statesn no deposit
    casino bonus codes, or netent no deposit bonus nz

    Feel free to surf to my webpage blackjack with friends app (Bryant)

  93. online gambling legal in united states, best united kingdom online casino
    skill based games (Russell) paypal and best australian casino sign up bonus, or online
    gambling canada illegal

  94. united states no deposit pokies, canadian pokie machines for sale how to play game
    and earn money (Terrance)
    $5 minimum deposit casino australia 2021, or new zealandn casino gambling craps tips

  95. free spins casino no deposit usa, best deposit 1 get free spins;
    Clay, bonus
    betting sites new zealand and new zealandn eagle slot machine,
    or olg online casino australia

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *